The Bank of England had been sounding more hawkish in recent weeks, but sweeping tariffs from US president Donald Trump could force it to take a more aggressive approach with interest rate cuts.
Markets are currently pricing in a 25 basis-point cut when the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) next meets on 8 May, but economists at Deutsche Bank believe a 50 basis-point cut is possible under certain circumstances.
It would take three things for the Bank to surprise markets with a larger-than-expected cut, Deutsche Bank said: a sharp drop-off in business activity, an excessive tightening of financial conditions, and further labour market cooling.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Get 6 issues free
Sign up to Money Morning
Don’t miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don’t miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
For now, Deutsche Bank’s base case is still four more rate cuts this year with the MPC sticking to 25 basis-point steps. However, it argues that the odds of faster rate cuts are growing as a result of Trump’s tariffs, “albeit from a low base”.
“If global headwinds intensify, financial conditions tighten, and the real economy shows clearer signs of slowing, then the MPC will likely opt to move faster rather than slower,” said Sanjay Raja, chief UK economist at the investment bank.
Former deputy BoE governor: rates should be cut to “at least 4% in May”
In an interview with The Guardian this week, former deputy governor of the Bank of England Charlie Bean said rates should be cut by “at least half a percentage point to 4%” in response to the tariff turmoil.
Bean said tariffs would force businesses to delay investments and consumers to be more cautious with their spending. This could pour ice water on economic growth.
The former deputy governor referred back to November 2008, when the Bank of England surprised markets with a 1.5 percentage-point cut.
“The markets expected a 0.25 percentage point cut, or maybe a half a percent. But we were talking to our agents in the regions and they said business orders had fallen off a cliff. It was obviously a very serious situation,” he told The Guardian.
Bean said the tariff situation is not of the same magnitude as the 2008 financial crisis, but still described it as a “disinflationary shock” and called on the Bank of England to “react very strongly”.
Are tariffs inflationary or disinflationary?
While most experts agree that tariffs will drag on growth, the impact on inflation is less clear. It is worth pointing out that the Bank of England has a dual mandate. As well as supporting growth, it needs to keep inflation under control.
Prices are likely to rise in the US in response to tariffs, as businesses pass import taxes on to consumers. Consultancy Capital Economics expects tariffs to add roughly 2.5 percentage points to the US CPI price level.
Global supply chains will also face disruption, which could push costs up more widely. However, this could be offset by a reduction in business activity and consumer spending.
James Smith, developed markets economist at European bank ING, said the fact that the UK government hasn’t retaliated means the impact on UK inflation should be minimal.
“If anything, it could prove deflationary further down the line as economic growth cools and the threat of dumping from other big global producers rises.”
Research company Pantheon Macroeconomics takes a different stance and believes prices could rise.
“Supply shocks, of which tariffs are an example, are stagflationary. So, we think that UK rate-setters will have to be more cautious about responding to weaker growth, weighting inflation more highly than usual,” said economist Robert Wood.
For this reason, Pantheon views a 50 basis-point cut in May as “very unlikely”.
“Ultimately, we are looking at a global stagflationary recession if Trump fails to change course soon. In that worst-case scenario, the MPC would likely respond with deeper rate cuts in late 2025 or early 2026.”
